Many of you have participated in our online Fund Category Awards and Fund House Awards polls in recent weeks, and will therefore be familiar with the new Morningstar Fund Awards programme. If you're not, you can click here for all the details (for the o
fficial methodology, click here), but suffice it to say that our overwhelming objective was to recognise those funds that had good performance in 2007, but--most importantly--had also delivered strong risk-adjusted returns for investors over the long haul, relative to appropriate benchmarks.
We know that there's often interest in who has fared best over a given year or three years, but such figures are often very poor predictors of who will do well in the future. We therefore focussed on one-, three-, and five-year performance, looking at how funds fared relative to their Morningstar Category peers, after adjusting for risk. To adjust for risk, we used the Morningstar Risk measure, a state-of-the-art measure which uses utility theory to penalise funds more for downside variation in returns than for upside volatility--in keeping with actual investor concerns.
We eliminated all institutional share classes from consideration for the awards, as these really are intended to help guide investors towards the best managers in their respective spaces. If a manager is good, he or she ought to be able to outperform even when carrying a full retail total expense ratio. Finally, our fund analysts employed a qualitative overlay to ensure that our choices hadn't suffered from major changes that might be expected to cause their future ability to outperform to differ markedly from the past. This meant, for example, that we did not select Fidelity Special Situations as the winner in the UK Mid-Cap Equity category.
So without further ado, here are the winners for the 2008 Morningstar Fund Category Awards. We won't detail each fund here, but investors will notice a common thread: From Invesco's Neil Woodford to First State's Angus Tulloch and Martin Lau, to Franklin Mutual's Philippe Brugere-Trelat, many of the funds selected exhibited a fundamentally-oriented, long-term approach to investing, and a willingness to go against the crowd. That's no accident: Following the herd is rarely a recipe for success, whilst original research and the courage to back your ideas with significant assets is often what sets the very best managers apart from the pack.
Award | Fund Name |
---|---|
Best UK Large-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Invesco Perpetual High Income Inc |
Best UK Mid-Cap/All-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | M&G Recovery A Acc |
Best UK Small-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Invesco Perpetual UK Smaller Companies Equity Inc |
Best Asia Pacific Equity Fund Award 2008 | First State Asia Pacific A Acc |
Best Emerging Markets Equity Fund Award 2008 | The Emerging World Fund Retail Acc |
Best Europe ex-UK Large-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Cazenove European Fund A Acc |
Best Europe Large-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Franklin Mutual European A Acc € |
Best Global Large-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Aberdeen Global World Equity Fund A Acc |
Best US Large-Cap Equity Fund Award 2008 | Henderson Horizon American Equity A2 Acc |
Best Sterling Corporate Bond Fund Award 2008 | Invesco Perpetual Corporate Bond Acc |
Morningstar UK Fund House Awards 2008
The principle for our fund house awards is largely the same as that of our Fund Category awards--to identify those groups that have delivered strong long-term risk adjusted performance. In this case, however, we used each house's average five-year Morningstar Rating? as our primary measure. It incorporates the same risk-adjustment calculation used in the Category Awards, but it places less emphasis on the one-year period than we used for the latter. We did this because we have found that the traits that make fund houses successful are largely structural in nature and should be manifest over the long haul if they really are in place. Things like incentive structures and recruitment procedures, attitudes towards costs, and an emphasis on original research may not lead a house to the top of the charts in any given year, but they should pay off over time. Please click here to learn more about the selection process for the Fund House Awards.
The winners of our Morningstar UK Fund House Awards 2008 are as follows:
Award | Fund House |
---|---|
Best Larger Equity Fund House Award 2008 | M&G |
Best Smaller Equity Fund House Award 2008 | Artemis |
Best Larger Fixed-Interest Fund House Award 2008 | Fidelity |
Best Smaller Fixed-Interest Fund House Award 2008 | Baillie Gifford |
Best Multi-Asset Fund House Award 2008 | Baillie Gifford |
We have significantly revised our awards programme this year. To download a spreadsheet of past awards, click here.