Our ego gives us confidence in our abilities and judgments. Taken too far, though, ego can cause long-lasting damage.
Here are four tips to keep your ego in check.
But first, here's three quick stories about how ego can affect decision-making, starting with how the US once planned to nuclear bomb the moon.
Jump to see our tips on how to protect your investments from your ego.
1. Shooting For The Moon
It’s 1958 and America’s still reeling from the Soviet launch of Sputnik 1, the world’s first artificial satellite.
Since the end of World War Two, the US and Soviet Union had been locked in a tit-for-tat nuclear arms race. Sputnik 1 signalled that it had evolved into a space race too.
The US feared it was falling behind the technology of its archrival. The question was: what could it do to boost flagging morale at home and, at the same time, show the Soviets and the world its military superiority?
Enter Project A119. The US Air Force approved the top-secret project, named "A Study of Lunar Research Flights".
It was led by leading physicist, Leonard Reiffel, who would go on to become Deputy Director of NASA’s Apollo space program.
The Air Force asked Reiffel to fast-track the project to examine the visibility and effects of a possible nuclear explosion on the surface of the moon.
Reiffel knew early on that the project wasn’t about technology but politics. He said later:
"It was clear the main aim of the proposed detonation was a PR exercise and a show of one-upmanship. The Air Force wanted a mushroom cloud so large it would be visible on earth."
It’s never been revealed how the nuclear device would have reached the moon, but Reiffel claimed it was technically feasible to hit the moon with an accuracy of within 3.2 kilometres. It’s likely that the mission would have included an intercontinental ballistic missile and the nuclear device would have been an atomic bomb.
In a 1959 report, Reiffel said that while the blast would be relatively small, it could come at a huge cost of contaminating the moon with radioactive material, and "if such biological contamination of the moon occurred, it would represent an unparalleled scientific disaster, eliminating several possibly very fruitful approaches to such problems as the early history of the solar system, the chemical composition of matter in the remote past, the origin of life on earth, and the possibility of extraterrestrial life."
That killed off the project.
News of the nuclear plans only came to light in the late 1990s. It was revealed then that the Soviet Union had a similar plan to the US at that time and it also got canned.
Thank goodness ego didn’t win out in this instance, though it nearly did four years later when the two Cold War combatants came perilously close to starting a nuclear war during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Jump ahead to our tips on keeping your ego in check.
2. Betting Big
In 1982, Jim Paul had it all. He was a star futures trader who served on the board of governors at the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. He made loads of money, travelled frequently, and was considered among the best at his craft. His confidence and money-making skills knew no bounds.
Then he had a trade which seemed like a sure thing. The soybean oil market was exceedingly tight as limited supply met still buoyant demand. Paul was sure that soybean prices were about to jump.
And he bet big on his convictions. His futures trades exceeded the limits on positions set by the Chicago Board of Trade. He even borrowed US$400,000 from friends to increase his personal position in the trade.
When soybean prices fell, Paul’s confidence didn’t waver. While his clients and other traders abandoned the trade, he held on. He ended up not only losing clients' money, but $1.6 million of his own, including that borrowed from friends. Unsurprisingly, he was fired.
Credit to him that he later wrote the book What I Learned Losing a Million Dollars.
3. A personal Story
To a personal story. I was once a relatively new equities portfolio manager, and I went on an offsite meeting with my team to discuss strategies for the year ahead. We had several new team members and our boss asked each of us what our goals were for the fund.
I was up first and answered, "I’m a competitive guy and want our fund to be among the best. I don’t want us to be like your typical benchmark-hugging fund".
I don’t recall many of the answers that followed except one from a senior team member, who said: "I want us to sustainably grow our clients’ wealth so they can help their families and possibly fund their retirements".
At that moment, I realised how lame my answer had been.
It was more than that. I reflected on how I’d let my ego affect other decisions I’d made as a portfolio manager.
A few weeks earlier, I got the investment fund into a stock which had fallen hard but where I felt business fundamentals would soon improve. I’d put our fund into a big, contrarian bet.
At the team meeting, I saw that I’d taken this large position to prove myself to the team and others. Put simply, it was an ego trip that put client money at risk.
How to Park Your Ego
These stories show how ego can affect decision making in all sorts of ways.
Life might be easier if we could just get rid of ego, yet that isn’t possible. It’s part of our identity. Ego gives us confidence in our abilities and judgments. Science suggests that confident people are more likely to be resilient and find professional success. And ego also protects us from the opinions and judgments of others.
Taken too far though, ego can cause long-lasting damage. In investing, too much self-confidence can destroy wealth, as it did with Jim Paul.
Four Tips to Straighten Your Ego:
What can be done to tame the ego?
I like Aristotle’s analogy of a warped piece of wood to describe human nature. To eliminate warping or curvature, a skilled woodworker slowly applies pressure in the opposite direction – essentially, bending it straight.
1. Turn down the competitive streak
We are trained to compete and win contests. From standardised testing at primary school through to sports and getting jobs, competition is about beating others and boosting your self-esteem. Done in moderation, it can be a good thing; taken too far, it can do harm.
In investing, too much focus on making more money than your neighbour will impact your decision making and returns.
2. Detach Ego From The Outcome
In markets, gains and losses can be taken personally, as a reflection of your self-worth. That’s the ego at work. But being right and making a profit aren’t necessarily the same thing. And being wrong and taking a loss aren’t the same either.
Jim Paul puts this eloquently in his book:
"Personalizing successes sets people up for disastrous failure. They begin to treat the successes totally as a personal reflection of their abilities rather than the result of capitalising on a good opportunity, being at the right place at the right time, or even being just plain lucky. They think their mere involvement in an undertaking guarantees success. This phenomenon has been called many things: hubris, overconfidence, arrogance. But the way in which successes become personalised and the processes that precipitate the subsequent failure have never been clearly spelled out."
3. Add a dose of humility
We can all heed the example of William Tecumseh Sherman, who rose from nothing to become a great general during the American civil war, but repeatedly turned down higher military titles, and promoted the successes of others for the good of his country.
A biographer said of him:
"Among men who rise to fame and leadership two types are recognisable: those who are born with a belief in themselves and those in whom it is a slow growth dependent on actual achievement. To men of the last type their own success is a constant surprise, and its fruits the more delicious, yet to be tested cautiously with a haunting sense of doubt whether it is not all a dream. In that doubt lies true modesty, not the sham of insincere self-depreciation but the modesty of 'moderation,' in the Greek sense. It is poise, not pose."
Poise over pose; humility over the ego.
4. Diversify your investments
Concentrated portfolios reflect self-confidence, or ego. In expert hands, they can work. In mere mortals, they can be a disaster. Having a diversified portfolio is the best way to keep your ego in check.
