In a volatile year for global stock markets, the chasm between the best and worst performing funds is a wide one. So how have sustainable funds held up through 2020 so far?
We have looked at UK-domiciled, actively managed funds to determine which are the top and bottom performers in the year to date. While the strongest fund is up an incredible 55%, the weakest is down by 32.9%.
The data shows that investing with ESG factors in mind doesn't mean giving up on juicy returns, even during an unexpected bear market. But clearly investors must still do their homework when choosing a fund.
Best Performing ESG Funds
The five-star rated Baillie Gifford Positive is the best performing fund this year, returning a hefty 55.5%. Needless to say, the fund has beaten its benchmark: while it aims to outperform the MSCI AC World Index by two percentage points a year, it is actually ahead of it by a considerably larger 35.5 percentage points.
What helped its performance is having a heavily concentrated portfolio of just 31 holdings, showing how picking the right companies can make you reap large rewards.
According to Morningstar Direct data, the main contributors to performance have been electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla (TSLA) and American biotech company Moderna (MRNA). Particularly Tesla, which is its largest holding, has had a stonking year and share price has soared an incredible 800%.
In second position, hot on its heels, is the five-star rated Baillie Gifford Global Stewardship, which has returned 54.8% In this case, among the main contributors to its performance are video conferencing platform Zoom (ZOOM) and California-based biotech company Denali Therapeutics (DENI). Both companies have benefited from the pandemic crisis as people have been working remotely and the need of a vaccine has become crucial.
Name | Morningstar Category | Return (%) |
Baillie Gifford Positive Change | Global Large-Cap Growth Equity | 55.5 |
Baillie Gifford Global Stewardship | Global Large-Cap Growth Equity | 54.8 |
Ninety One Global Environment | Sector Equity Ecology | 27.3 |
Liontrust Sustainable Future Global Growth | Global Large-Cap Growth Equity | 18.6 |
Janus Henderson Global Sustainable Equity | Global Flex-Cap Equity | 17.9 |
Rathbone Global Sustainability | Global Large-Cap Growth Equity | 17.0 |
CCLA CBF CoE Global Equity Income | Global Equity Income | 15.7 |
VT Gravis Clean Energy Income | Sector Equity Alternative Energy | 13.8 |
Stewart Inv Asia Pacific Sustainability | Asia-Pacific ex-Japan Equity | 13.7 |
Stewart Inv Worldwide Sustainability | Global Large-Cap Growth Equity | 13.6 |
Worst Performing ESG Funds
At the other side of the spectrum are, mostly, sustainable funds with a UK focus. This comes as a little surprise, as the UK stock market has been struggling to catch up with other developed markets, amid uncertainty over Brexit and coronavirus cases on the rise.
The worst performing ESG fund year to date is the three-star rated Schroder Responsible Value UK Equity, down 32.9%. This means that is 10.6 percentage points behind its UK Large-Cap Equity benchmark.
The main detractors to its performance are energy and financial companies – two sectors that have took the brunt of the pandemic crisis. In particular, its second larger holding BP (5.1% of its assets) has halved this year after a dividend cut and slump in oil demand.
Furthermore, half of the funds in the table are also income focused. These are: the five-star rated Unicorn UK Ethical Income, AI Stewardship UK Equity Income, the three-star rated Jupiter Responsible Income, the four-star rated Janus Henderson UK Responsible Income and BMO Responsible UK Income.
Indeed income investors have had a particularly rough time this year, with many companies cutting their dividends in the attempt to support their finances.
Name | Morningstar Category | Return (%) |
Schroder Responsible Value UK Equity | UK Large-Cap Equity | -32.9 |
Unicorn UK Ethical Income | UK Equity Income | -26.6 |
ASI UK Ethical Equity | UK Flex-Cap Equity | -24.1 |
Family Charities Ethical Trust | UK Large-Cap Equity | -23.8 |
AI Stewardship UK Equity Income UK | UK Equity Income | -22.4 |
L&G Ethical | UK Large-Cap Equity | -21.9 |
Jupiter Responsible Income | UK Equity Income | -21.6 |
Scottish Widows Ethical | UK Flex-Cap Equity | -21.5 |
Janus Henderson UK Responsible Income | UK Equity Income | -21.5 |
BMO Responsible UK Income | UK Equity Income | -21.4 |